I have always been a liquid liner + pencil liner combo user! I use Liquid Liner for upper lashline and pencil liner for the waterline! That has been the best way for me to brighten up my eye.
I have my own favorites yet I always strive to look for the best in the market. One brand that caught my attention is the Eye Of Horus and they created Goddess Pencil inspired by Egyptian Goddess, I mean, who has better-looking liner than Egyptian right?
Eye Of Horus is a brand that uses ingredients used during the ancient times --- Ancient Moringa Oil, Ancient Malachite and a whole lot more. I may not be knowledgeable with all the ingredients but all I know (and is thankful for) are the products are all cruelty-free!
Eye of Horus Dual Brow Perfect Says ---
Eye of Horus Goddess Pencils is a pencil eyeliner with a waterproof, longwearing and creamy formula. It is formulated with beeswax, organic moringa oil and carnauba and candelilla waxes. It features a smudge tip for blending colour. The eyeliner is paraben-free, non-irritating and suitable for sensitive eye areas. Available in: Smokey Black, Teal Malachite, Bronze Amulet, Scarab Sapphire, Emerald Tabula, Charcoal Obsidian, Nubian Brown, Sultry Serpentine, Lazuli Blue, Jewel Amethyst and new shades, Selenite White and Sahara Nude.